Hong Kong Lucida

A Thinking Street Photography Blog

Anecdote of the Jar

I’m not sure if this is considered street photography, but I suppose so, if street photography is about scenes that are found rather than staged, about scenes that say something about the interactions between human beings and their environment.

For those interested in film photography: all photographs are taken with Contax TVS, loaded with Superia Venus 800. That’s the gear I carry these days. This post is inspired by Wallace Stevens’ poem, “Anecdote of the Jar”:

I placed a jar in Tennessee,

And round it was, upon a hill.

It made the slovenly wilderness

Surround that hill.

 

The wilderness rose up to it,

And sprawled around, no longer wild.

The jar was round upon the ground

And tall and of a port in air.

 

It took dominion everywhere.

The jar was gray and bare.

It did not give of bird or bush,

Like nothing else in Tennessee.

 

A quick Google search will reveal various possible readings to the poem, so I’ll suppress my inner poetry geek as much as I can.

 

I’ll simply say that at the minimum, the poem is about the relationship between human artifacts and nature.

 

The take-away philosophical point is that a man-made object placed/installed in nature changes nature.

IMG_20140526_0005 640

Is nature a rubbish dump, a depository of things no longer useful?

 

The joker in me tells me it’s a supermarket shopping cart that has lost its way.

IMG_20140526_0008 640

Nature is nature.

 

A journey into what nature is is man-made.

IMG_20140526_0009 640

Is nature a resource we exploit?

 

I am reminded of the following lines from Heidegger’s essay “The Question Concerning Technology’ , about how our instrumentalist attitude to nature (and everything else) reduces everything into a “standing-reserve”, as means for other ends:

 

Everywhere everything is ordered to stand by, to be immediately at hand, indeed to stand there just so that it may be on call for a further ordering. (Heidegger “Question Concerning Technology”)

IMG_20140526_0019 640

We’ve learnt to frame nature.

IMG_20140526_0026 640

And in our arrogance, we forget it is nature that frames us.

IMG_20140526_0027 640

Perhaps we’re the ones putting obstacles between ourselves and nature, between ourselves and ourselves.

Advertisements

4 comments on “Anecdote of the Jar

  1. janicewasabi
    June 9, 2014

    that first picture–brilliant!!!!
    reminds me of a certain Bansky work (I forgot the name), or maybe this http://uncyclopedia.wikia.com/wiki/File:Waterlilies.jpg

    • eddietay
      June 11, 2014

      Thanks for the comparison, Janice! Fascinating, that one…
      🙂

  2. philosophoenix
    June 16, 2014

    I loved reading this and looking at your images. It certainly does stir my brain to think about how we interpose ourselves upon nature, and how we divide ourselves from it. The divisions are illusory, just as the objective perspective–in science, art, or society–is a construct. Though it may be perceived as a necessity within the laboratory, when we carry it out into the world with us, it is an obstruction to understanding.
    When we divide ourselves from an experience, we sacrifice something vital. In the name of that Western plate-glass distance, we divorce ourselves from the rich textures of meaning that are to be found everywhere. I have a number of photographer friends, though I have no such skills myself, and they constantly tell me that when framing an image, one of their tools is to be mindful not to remove themselves from the context. The stories told by their work depend upon their ability to render the sensory impressions of that work, not tell the story of how they use their cameras to distance themselves from life.
    I look forward to reading much more from you in the very near future.

    • eddietay
      June 16, 2014

      Thank you for this. This is insightful indeed! I often feel I’m mucking around, learning to use street photography as a tool for thinking.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: